Hey there
I know I've emailed you a few times this week. Forgive me, I normally keep it more chill than that.
But I have a good one for today, then I'll go back to my normal routine next week. 😅
It's Oaks Day today, and the Kentucky Derby's tomorrow. I have a story that actually pulls from my experience with working with Churchill Downs' Kentucky Derby Museum, the architecture firm that designed the famed twin spires, and the park where my wedding reception was.
You probably weren't expecting a ghost story about brand storytelling today, but that's what you're getting.
Happy Friday. Enjoy the story.
The Crazy Story Hiding Inside the Twin Spires
The most iconic landmark in horse racing was in-spired by an insane asylum. I'd think I was the crazy one saying that, had I not learned it firsthand.
Tomorrow 150K+ people at Churchill Downs Racetrack will look up at the Twin Spires and feel something (besides the Mint Juleps, LOL).
Some will feel nostalgia from when they went as a kid. Others will be soaking in the magic of being so close to legendary horses and jockeys.
None of them will be thinking of an insane asylum and the haunted grounds it left behind.
They're missing that part because it's been cut from the narrative.
The famous Twin Spires were designed in 1895 by a 24-year-old architect named Joseph Baldez.
When you read the official story from Kentucky Derby Museum (previous client of mine), they'll tell you he felt the grandstand "needed something to give it a striking appearance." The spires were just a decorative finish.
That is true, but Churchill Downs leaves out the whole story.
Baldez worked at D.X. Murphy & Brother, which is now known as Luckett & Farley. When looking at the plans for Churchill, Baldez made a legacy making suggestion:
What if we added two spires on the top?
That story's still told to this day.
What's usually left out is that Baldez was almost certainly inspired by the spires on top of the now-gone Central Kentucky Lunatic Asylum.
That asylum's main administration building had two prominent steeples and was an architectural icon at the time. The spire inspiration is clear to see when you see them in this picture.
I learned this over a decade ago when I led the rebrand for that famed firm, Luckett & Farley, which is one of the longest continuously run firms in the country.
It's an incredible story, with dark corners when you zoom in:
▪️ A documented 900 people were buried in and around what is now Tom Sawyer Park in Louisville.
▪️ Some have estimated that more than 5,000 unmarked graves exist in the area.
I've run hundreds of miles in Tom Sawyer Park. My wedding reception was there. I have many great memories there, and one creepy one.
One time when walking my dog there at dusk, he started barking at a tree that was over 100 yards away.
I decided to let him check it out. As we got closer, I realized there were grave stones I couldn't see from that distance.
The dog was LOCKED on one stone, as if he could sense something I couldn't see.
This was before I knew the folklore. We still high tailed it out of there. I was truly creeped out. It felt like something or someone was watching me.
Even worse are the stories of Sauerkraut Cave, but that's too much for a newsletter. You can Google that yourself.
The asylum building was ultimately torn down, as it was deemed to be too far gone. But you have to wonder if they really just wanted a clean slate for a building with so much baggage.
Annnnyways.
Happy Oaks Day / Derby Day to those who celebrate. When you're looking at the Twin Spires and feel something deep inside of you or in awe of their simplistic beauty, just know you're not alone.
Or crazy.
Parting Thoughts
There is a bit of a lesson here in this weird, creepy story about a Louisville icon. It's notable that both Luckett & Farley and Churchill Downs seemingly have removed the asylum connection to their story.
In this instance, it's fair to assume they just don't want to bring in the association with a place that could be responsible for up to 5,000 unmarked graves (and worse), right?
While this is an extreme example, I see this with brands all the time who keep things in their story Because it's just how it was. But often the positioning of our story is not what we decide to say, but also what we decide to leave out.
This is very much part of what we decide when we do our brand audits and our story positioning and messaging work. It's something you should be thinking about as a leader within your company.
Alright, time to shut up and go enjoy my Oaks Day. I'm hitting hitting the road bike and listening to the new John Shambles album. Then it's two Derby parties tomorrow. You?
Thanks for reading,
Brad Luttrell
Founder
Prologue